Texas vs. California

Understanding California’s Housing Crisis

California is in the middle of a severe housing crisis. In fact, it is one of the most pressing social and political issues of our time. Ken Miller, an esteemed professor at Claremont McKenna College and the author of Texas v. California, explains that the housing crisis is the public policy failure in the last 50 years. “It is probably the single biggest public policy failure in California that I can think of over the last generation and the biggest challenge moving forward.” This crisis is a multifaceted problem entangled with population growth, economic disparity, and state policy, deeply impacting the Californian dream.

The Roots of the Housing Crisis

An icon of a person stands across from a house separated by a deep canyon, representing the housing crisis.

At the heart of California’s housing crisis lies a failure in public policy, deeply rooted in a complex web of regulatory constraints, insufficient housing supply, and affordability challenges. Over the years, these policy shortcomings have stifled new housing development and exacerbated the affordability crisis, making it increasingly difficult for average Californians to own or even rent homes. In fact, 90% of Californians consider housing affordability a significant problem. 

The state’s stringent zoning laws and environmental regulations have often led to prolonged delays and increased costs in housing development. Furthermore, this policy paralysis has not kept pace with the state’s population growth, leading to a significant mismatch between housing demand and supply. 

Ken observes, “Home ownership is a big part of what we have thought of as the American dream. It’s the basis for creating wealth and becoming financially secure in one’s life.” However, due to a combination of regulatory hurdles, high costs of living, and inadequate supply, the dream of owning a home has become increasingly unattainable for many Californians. For example, in Los Angeles County, only 11% of the population can afford a home at the current median price. 

Population Growth and Economic Disparity

California, once the promised land for many Americans, doubled in population from 1970 to 2020, but is now hemorrhaging population to other states. This exodus is driven in no small part by unaffordable housing. Ken says: “We have by far more billionaires in California than in any other state… And then we have the highest poverty rate in the nation by a substantial margin if it’s adjusted for the cost of living.”

Once, the middle class was willing to pay a “premium” to live in California due to its stunning natural beauty, comfortable climate, and economic opportunity. Now, many people are finding the “premium” is simply too expensive. California is experiencing a hollowing-out of the middle class, leaving behind the wealthy and the poor. California is becoming a modern-day feudal state.

Comparative Analysis with Other States

Consequently, the beneficiaries are states like Texas and California. “Those are the new growth areas in the United States. And that’s where people are going in order to buy a home, raise a family, start a new company and such,” Professor Miller states. In fact, Texas today looks a lot like the California of the 1950s and 60s. 

It’s a troubling trend: California’s once magnetic appeal is waning under the weight of its economic policies and the deepening housing crisis. Once heralded for its innovation and opportunities, the state now grapples with issues that deter new residents and businesses. 

California’s once magnetic appeal has waned under the weight of its economic policies and the deepening housing crisis. Once heralded for its innovation and opportunities, the state now grapples with issues that deter new residents and businesses. As states like Texas and Florida offer more affordable living and favorable economic conditions, they increasingly draw away both individuals and businesses seeking better prospects. The ability to work remotely greases the skids of this outflow.

A graphic of a dollar sign, downward red arrow, and a house, representing the housing crisis in California.

The Future Outlook and Challenges

As California grapples with these housing challenges, the state’s future economic stability and growth are in question. While the state is the wealthiest in the nation, it also has the highest poverty rates. The housing crisis impacts current residents and has broader implications for attracting new talent and businesses. The housing market has become a significant barrier to entry for many potential homeowners and renters. This market trend is not sustainable, as it widens the gap between high-income earners and those struggling to afford basic housing.

To address this, solutions could include streamlining the approval process for new housing developments, revising zoning laws to increase density, and providing incentives for affordable housing projects. Additionally, implementing policies that encourage public-private partnerships could be instrumental in addressing the housing supply shortage, making it more feasible for a broader range of residents to find affordable housing options in California.

Discover More

California’s economic stability and viability is in question. Is Sacramento up to the challenge? Learn more about the complexities of California’s housing crisis and engage in conversations about shaping a sustainable and accessible future for housing in the state. Be sure to check out the latest episode of the New Majority Podcast for more insights.

Join Our Movement for Positive Change

Engage with the Fourscore & Seven Project Video Series, available here and on our YouTube channel. By watching, liking, and subscribing, you’re taking a step towards fostering a democratic and transparent government and critically thinking about California’s social issues.

Support Our Vision — Donate Today

Your contribution to the New Majority Foundation furthers our mission of creating a well-informed and engaged community. Donate today and be part of the change. Together, we can make a transformative impact on California and beyond.