Election Integrity In America

A Comprehensive EXPLORATION

Election integrity is the cornerstone of democratic governance, ensuring every citizen’s voice is valued and counted. In today’s rapidly evolving voting landscape, from the advent of mail-in balloting to debates surrounding ballot harvesting, it’s imperative to understand the intricacies, challenges, and potential solutions that can preserve the integrity of our electoral process.

As America’s voting systems continue to evolve, the push for increased accessibility can be at odds with the necessity for secure and reliable voting. This balancing act has far-reaching implications for our democracy and underlines the complexities of maintaining election integrity.

The Evolution of Ballot Harvesting


Originally, ballot harvesting was a well-intentioned system designed to assist individuals facing barriers like language difficulties or physical disabilities. Over time, this has expanded into broader collection efforts, sometimes referred to as “ballot trafficking.” 

While early voting and mail-in ballots aim to make voting more convenient and accessible, they open new doors for discrepancies and abuse. Unfortunately, the shift from individual assistance to more generalized collection methods poses challenges to electoral integrity, offering loopholes that various interest groups could exploit. Derek Lyons, a Harvard educated attorney and president and CEO of the prestigious Washington based organization, Restoring Integrity and Trust in Elections, observes, “While we aim to include and assist every voter, it’s imperative we safeguard the process from potential misuse.”

Mail-in Balloting: An Era of Convenience and Controversy

States like California have shifted to mailing ballots to all registered voters, affording unparalleled convenience. Yet, as Derek Lyons points out, “With convenience, we must ensure accuracy, or we risk undermining the very foundation of our democratic process.” But with people relocating or being registered in multiple states, managing this new convenience becomes a complex task.

The Significance of Clean Voter Rolls

Registering to vote has become easier over the years, thanks to online portals and automatic voter registration at the Department of Motor Vehicles in some states. But the ease of registration doesn’t always equate to clean voter rolls. People move, pass away, or even be registered in multiple states accidentally, leading to bloated and outdated lists.

Maintaining accurate voter rolls is a technical challenge and a matter of political will. “An accurate roll isn’t just a list; it’s a testament to the fairness of our electoral process,” says Lyons. When voter rolls are not regularly updated, they can become breeding grounds for discrepancies and fraudulent activities, potentially undermining the legitimacy of election outcomes.

The Ambiguity of Voter Verification

A "Sorry We're Closed" sign hangs on a business door because of public safety concerns.

Voter identification at polling places is another hot-button issue. While aimed at preventing voter impersonation, opponents argue that strict ID requirements can disenfranchise certain groups, particularly those who may not have easy access to identification documents.

States vs. Federal Oversight: Striking the Right Balance

The decentralized nature of America’s electoral system — where each state sets its own voting policies — creates an environment ripe for experimentation and tailored approaches. Traditionally, states have maintained control over their voting systems, reflecting their unique cultures and election methods. 

However, it also introduces inconsistency and the potential for confusion or abuse. While interstate systems like ERIC help to maintain cleaner voter rolls, the tension between state autonomy and federal standardization persists. “The balance between autonomy and standardized oversight is delicate; our goal should be to harmonize, not monopolize,” Lyons stresses.

Creating a Robust Election Integrity Framework

The changing dynamics in voting methods, legislative frameworks, and the balance of power between state and federal oversight necessitate a proactive approach. Understanding the complexity of these systems allows us to identify vulnerabilities and implement effective safeguards.

By advocating for transparent processes and championing electoral integrity, we can collectively ensure that every citizen’s voice is heard and every vote counted. But it must be done in a way that is fair and free of potential abuse. This affirms the very foundations of our democratic principles.

Learn More About Election Integrity by Listening to the New Majority Podcast

For deeper insights into these critical issues, tune in to our recent New Majority Podcast episode focusing on election integrity.

Your engagement matters. Together, we can bolster the sanctity and fairness of our electoral system, ensuring that democracy remains vibrant and robust.

Join Our Movement for Positive Change

Engage with the Fourscore & Seven Project Video Series, available here and on our YouTube channel. By watching, liking, and subscribing, you’re taking a step towards fostering a democratic and transparent government and critically thinking about California’s social issues.

Support Our Vision — Donate Today

Your contribution to the New Majority Foundation furthers our mission of creating a well-informed and engaged community. Donate today and be part of the change. Together, we can make a transformative impact on California and beyond.